The 20 Most Damage-Prone Cars, According to Traffic Statistics

Road Traffic Accidents in the USWhen road traffic accidents occur, the blame often goes to the person behind the wheel, not the crashed vehicle itself. Even so, it’s hard not to admit that the type of vehicle driven affects the accident’s chances of occurring in the first place.

Although substantial evidence exists pointing to human error as the cause of virtually all car crashes, there is a blind spot for the type of vehicles commonly chosen by bad drivers. At least until a few years ago.

According to a report published by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), there exists a significant distinction between car models in terms of their susceptibility to damage. Below you will find a list of the 20 most damage-prone vehicles in the US, all followed by their “collision loss experience” rating, which begins at 100 (the base percentage) and increases according to their likelihood of getting into a crash:

  1. Ferrari 458 Italia – 546
  2. Bentley Continental GT – 517
  3. Ferrari California Convertible – 427
  4. Maserati GranTurismo Convertible – 405
  5. Maserati Quattroporte – 404
  6. Bentley Continental GTC Convertible – 394
  7. BMW X6 M – 380
  8. Porsche Panamera Turbo – 353
  9. Maserati GranTurismo Coupe – 322
  10. Nissan GT-R – 318
  11. Mercedes-Benz G-Class – 316
  12. Mercedes-Benz SLS-Class Coupe – 304
  13. Audi A8L – 298
  14. BMW M3 Coupe, 297
  15. Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 – 292
  16. BMW 6 Series – 289
  17. BMW 6 Series Convertible – 284
  18. Mercedes-Benz CLS-Class with all-wheel drive – 272
  19. Jaguar XJ (long wheelbase) – 267
  20. Mercedes-Benz CLS-Class – 262

Of course, with data on the most damage-prone cars, there must also be statistically safest vehicle to use. Auto accident attorneys cite the Jeep Wrangler as that vehicle, while the NHTSA identifies “micro cars”, “mini sports cars”, and “midsize station wagons” as the vehicle types least susceptible to damage.

Russ Rader, an Insurance Institute for Highway Safety spokesman, explains the findings by noting how “safer” options are common work vehicles, particularly in rural areas. “Low-severity fender-bender crashes, which are the dominant crashes in these data, are less likely to happen in rural areas than in urban ones,” he says.